There truly is just one reason why USA Men’s soccer will never perform at an elite level… and the reason is the USA itself.
The USA does not care about soccer even remotely close to 50+ other countries in the world.
See Our Podcast here on Spotify but it is also available on all streaming platforms.
THE USA DOES NOT CARE ABOUT SOCCER
It is absolutely ludicrous to have lofty expectations when every stat has soccer ranked anywhere from 4th to 6th in the USA for sports viewership.
Viewership gets even worse if you break out sports by leagues because soccer will fall even more once you separate the NFL and college football as well as the NBA and college basketball.
On top of that there are other college sports to compete with… unless you went to the schools playing, you would never watch college soccer.
Meanwhile the Frozen Four in hockey is well publicized, as is the College World Series and even the Little League World Series is more well known than any annual youth or adult soccer event in the USA!
Then we have the UFC & F1 now cutting into the big 5 sports viewership as well as every other new entertainment option people have nowadays vs. 20-30 years ago you basically had the “Big 5” sports and boxing on limited cable options.
Let’s not even get into the MLS, which in most studies and polls is the 9th-12th+ most watched sports league in the USA behind sometimes the G League, WWE, Bellator, Golf, WNBA and then of course miles ahead are Nascar, F1, IndyCar, NFL, NBA, NCAAFB, NCAAMBB, MLB, Hockey and UFC.
With all of that said… how can USA fans, pundits, players ever expect to have an elite level soccer program if the county does not care.
Do you know who cares about soccer? Every single Uruguayan, Croatian, Ghanaian, Belgian, Brazilian, Moroccan, Argentinian, Brit, Chilean and the list goes on.
In 50+ other counties soccer isn’t the 4th or 5th or 6th most watched and played sport… it is #1.
You won’t hear about Chileans chastising their American Football team or England berating their basketball team… for the exact same reason USA should not be upset with their soccer team.
If you visit Latin American countries you will find kids 24/7 playing with torn up deflated balls, sometimes barefoot, on cement courts that are falling apart or dirt patches… this not only is great for their touch and toughness but also just shows how much they love the sport.
As most everyone says, imagine if the USA had Lebron, Justin Jefferson, Patrick Mahomes, Jayson Tatum, Travis Kelce, Jon Bones Jones, Bryce Harper, Ja Morant, Anthony Edwards, Jalen Hurts, Tyreek Hill, Julio Rodriguez, Sean O’Malley etc playing soccer, the USA would dominate… well 50+ other countries have their versions of these people playing soccer!
This alone is why the USA will never ever be great at soccer and the expectations need to be tempered as such.
Americans you don’t want to hear this but… Team USA Men’s soccer will live in tier 2 or 3 of soccer teams forever and once in a while be that great story like Iceland in the 2016 Euro Cup or Morocco in the 2022 World Cup.
I don’t care what the nonsensical FIFA rankings say, the USA are not unquestionably a top 15 team in the world and they in fact should and will always live in the same tier with the likes of Denmark, Morocco, Japan, Senegal, Ghana, Ukraine, Austria, Poland and others in that realm.
If you are a soccer fan and you watched a USA or even a Canada game, then you watched a Euro Cup game… it is like watching pub soccer vs. elite teams.
USA & Canada over-dribble, make poor decisions, have a poor touch, kick it long too often and it’s just awful to watch compared to most European teams who make the ball do the work, only pass to high percentage options, keep the ball short and all else that comes with proper football.
TEAM USA USED TO HAVE GREAT RESULTS: FALSE
Then of course some of fans, along with ex-USA player pundits, may point to earlier days of the USA being glory years with amazing results… this is categorically false as well.
Past results were just as up and down with maybe a year of moderate success but nothing amazing as you will see below.
Here are the Team USA Men’s World Cup Results:
- 1954-1986 – Did not qualify
- 1990 – 23rd
- 1994 – 14th
- 1998 – 32nd
- 2002 – 8th
- 2006 – 25th
- 2010 – 12th
- 2014 – 15th
- 2018 – DNQ
- 2022 – 14th
Here Are the Team USA Men’s Copa America Results:
- 1993 – 12th
- 1995 – 4th
- 1997-2004 – Not Invited
- 2007 – 12th
- 2011-2015 – Not Invited
- 2016 – 4th
- 2019-2021 – Not Invited
- 2024 – 11th
*You may ask why Team USA was not invited to some Copa Americas. The tourney is a South American tournament and only Mexico has been invited to play in it more than the USA, even Canada has only been invited for the first time in 2024.
Team USA Men’s Gold Cup Results:
- 1963-1984 – Did Not Enter or Did Not Qualify
- 1985 – 6th
- 1989 – 2nd
- 1991 – 1st
- 1993 – 2nd
- 1996 – 3rd
- 1998 – 2nd
- 2000 – 5th
- 2002 – 1st
- 2003 – 3rd
- 2005 & 2007 – 1st
- 2009 & 2011 – 2nd
- 2013 – 1st
- 2015 – 4th
- 2017 – 1st
- 2019 – 2nd
- 2021 – 1st
- 2023 – 4th
Conclusion On Results
Drawing from these results one could say there was a Golden Year (not generation), in 2002 when USA finished 8th in the World Cup & won the Gold Cup…
However, in 1998 that “2000 generation” finished 32nd in the World Cup then 5th in the 2000 Gold Cup and 3rd in the 2003 Gold Cup.
Thus, this wasn’t exactly some golden era, it was a golden blip. Similar to what I mentioned before regarding the USA making a run once in a couple decades a la Morocco or Iceland.
You could then say 2005 & 2007 was nice because they won the Gold Cup… yet they then finished 12th in the Copa America and in 2006 finished 25th in the World Cup… again no Golden Generation.
All in all the USA has had one good, not great, year… not necessarily some historic run or Golden Generation.
Let’s also remember the Gold Cup is a weak tournament with really only Mexico or the USA being perineal World Cup teams. So a Gold Cup win, congrats on beating Pamana, Curacao & Honduras etc.
I wouldn’t hang my hat on the Gold Cup being a barometer for greatness or a high level of success.
Okay But, The Team USA Players Are Great Now Though… right?
Again… hold your eagles… Team USA players are not great right now and never have been great, for the reasons I went over before and will more below.
Christian Pulisic is a nice player… he is not ranked in the top 100 players in the world, look it up. His value was not even top 10 in the Copa America tourney.
Transfermarket.com has Pulisic at 148th ranked in the world.
Sure he had a nice year in Serie A… but Serie A is consistently ranked 3rd, 4th or 5th best league in the world. 37-year-old Olivier Giroud is at the top of goals and assists, as is Romelu Lukaku who continually couldn’t hack it in England… it is a retirement league with some top players sprinkled in.
Pulisic does well against weaker competition like games against Bolivia or in Serie A… but then over dribbles and has an awful passing percentage against the likes of Uruguay or missing sitters for Chelsea when the pressure is on.
Tranfermarket.com has Folarin Balogun 250th ranked and Giovanni Reyna isn’t even ranked as he is hurt constantly.
Let’s go back in time… Landon Donovan is the best USA men’s player ever… he played in the MLS… He appeared in the German Bundesliga 35 times and was loaned to the MLS from there… he then went on loan to Bayern Munich playing 6 games and Everton for 17 games over 3 years… this is outside top 100 players in the world.
Clint Dempsey one might argue was the best American player ever as he actually excelled in the EPL, albeit at a low level and often relegated team in Fulham. Again a really nice player and great American… but not top 100 in the world.
You could also add in Tim Howard and Brad Friedel who also had nice careers as goalies in the EPL but again, we aren’t talking consistent top 100 players in the world here.
The point being… Team USA does not and never has had any great players. USA does not even have consistent top 100 in the world players let alone generational players.
With that said, why do we expect Team USA to be great when their best players are only ever “good” and maybe once in a blue-moon one is “really good.”
Why Is Team USA’s Women’s Team Good Then?
The quick & simple answer… history and overall women’s equality being much more advanced in the USA than around the world… the land of the free as they say.
The Football Association banned women’s soccer from 1921-1970. England, Germany, Spain, Brazil, France, Scotland and more outright banned women’s soccer until this time as well.
With that said, the USA started with an equal footing to other countries in terms of women’s soccer and were not behind the 8-ball when it came to practice, talent and all else.
This also meant the USA women saw some early success, which then turned into fans and young women wanting to play and grow the sport helping the USA stay on top, and as mentioned the USA loves a winner.
Sadly, it is far too late for men’s soccer to ever do this. Men’s soccer in the USA started a century later than other countries and by the time if picked up steam it already was the 4th/5th/6th men’s sport in the USA.
Where, you could argue that women’s soccer from the start was equal or greater in popularity to baseball & basketball for women.
Yes, I simplified it as there is more to it but that is the gist.
So what does this all mean? Why Can’t The USA Men’s Team Be Good At Soccer?
It means men’s Team USA has never been good, it has never been an elite program and honestly, it never will be.
However, the good news, this isn’t anyones fault, it isn’t USA Soccer’s fault, it isn’t players or coaches faults… it is the USA expectations.
Sure the USA loves a winner and will be die hard swimming fans for 2 weeks over the Olympics or Tour de France enthusiasts during the Lance Armstrong days.
Thus, winning could maybe right the ship, yet this will never happen as it is too late… and it is sort of like the chicken or the egg dilemma where winning will increase popularity but popularity is needed to increase winning.
So what do US fans do… you lower your expectations, you support the team, enjoy the games and that’s it.
What you don’t do… lose your mind every time the team is mediocre or middle of the pack… as this is just it.
Americans love to be the best at everything and it is what makes it the most powerful country in the world… unfortunately it just is never going to happen for men’s soccer.


