I started writing a Sleepers & Busts article but the title just didn’t seem right.
First, “sleepers” don’t really exist anymore as everyone knows about everything these days with the plethora of media out there. Second, calling someone a bust seems a little over the top just because they might be a little overvalued or maybe got injured.
Matthew Berry has his love/hate column and I felt “hate” is a little strong for a pretend sport of fantasy football… aside from week 8 last year and Jimmy G royally f****** Davante Adams owners in guillotine leagues, then I totally get it as I did hate him then.
With that said, I came up with buy at a low value & sell/fade at too high projected value seems to be a perfect marriage for this exercise where I tell you who you really should be valuing and devaluing based on their overall Average Draft Position (ADP).
BTW, be sure to read my 15 Fantasy Football Commandments for 2024 here!
Overall the goal is getting the best return on investment (ROI) you can via by getting the most value out of your pick whether it is a draft spot or auction price.
As I mention a lot, you really need to be treating fantasy football like the stock market, just not in the way my friend Dean sees the stock market… but regular sane people.
You should be looking for value first and foremost in a stock/player you can buy low that will give huge returns. You also might want consistency and maybe sprinkle in some risk pending your lifestyle choices.
Checkout my podcast on spotify below, which is streaming on all services.
Some people are risk averse and just keep it safe, but others may take some chances on some high risk high reward options… or a nice 80/20 mix.
With that said, let’s get into players you should be buying at a low ADP value who will significantly outperform their draft ADP and fade players who will end up with stats much lower than their current ADP.
For the sake of consistency I will use ESPN’s Points Per Reception (PPR) ADP for this exercise. PPR has surpassed “Standard” or non-PPR scoring leagues so I use PPR scoring since it is more common.
You can find their rankings via this link here.
I am not excited whatsoever to write this article as I know it is just going to end up with my friends reading this and sewering me in our auction drafts.
Thus, please realize I am doing this for the greater good as it probably will end up killing all my teams going forward…
Reminder, these are ADPs from ESPN’s PPR Draft Trends from August 20th, 2024 so they will change.
Fantasy Football Players To Buy Low For 2024
These are players I see that will far exceed their ADP and bring you an incredible ROI.
Josh Jacobs, RB, Green Bay Packers
Currently: ADP 41 | RB 15
Will Finish: ADP Top 20 | RB Top 5
Big facts: Josh Jacobs is only 26-years-old. I would have thought he was 30 with how long it seems he has been around.
The Green Bay Packers will win the NFC North and end as a top 2 seed in the NFC if not first, meaning they should play in front often.
The Raiders finished 3rd last in rushing last year while the Packers team is by far the best and most stable team Jacobs has ever played on.
New really good team, something to prove after a rough 2023, the positivity that comes with winning vs. the dumpster fire that is the Raiders organization and Jacobs is going to absolutely crush this season.
Last year he saw stacked boxes as we saw the Raiders cycle through QBs who couldn’t hit arguably the best WR in the NFL running wide open on multiple plays on a fateful Oct. 30th, 2023…
Raiders QB play on offense was so bad they literally brought in Gardner Minshew to be their starter.
This year Jacobs is playing with a potentially elite QB for the first time in his life and a passing offense that will open a ton of holes when it is time for Jacobs to run the ball.
He is still so young and is just one year removed from leading the league in rushing yards on a team that went 6-11, which typically is not a breeding ground for great RB play.
I also don’t expect as much of a timeshare as we have seen in Packers years past. With Jacobs being an elite level RB talent in prime age and with AJ Dillon looking running out of space to live up to the hype and talent.
Some people have Jacobs as a bust this year… I think they just don’t understand players or sports, especially a RB who need positive play around them to sacrifice their bodies at the extreme level they do each game.
Jacobs had nothing to play for last year and was injured… now he is on a team with legit Super Bowl aspirations.
Not many players are running through a wall for the raiders to finish under .500 for the 6th time in 7 years… they will for a team heading for the NFC Championship game.
George Pickens, WR, Pittsburgh Steelers
Currently: ADP 74 | WR 29
Will Finish: ADP Top 40 | WR Top 12
Big facts: George Pickens finished 30th in PPR scoring at WR last year… he was WR2 on his own team, he had one of the worst QB rooms in the league and one of the worst offensive coordinators who was fired midseason.
Pickens is now WR1 on his team, has 2 actual NFL starting calibre QBs and is only going 1 place higher per his ADP this year! Make it make sense.
In 2023 Pittsburgh was the 6th worst passing team in terms of yardage and 2nd worst in passing TDs.
In 2022 they were 9th worst in passing yards and dead last in passing TDs with 20% less passing TDs then 2nd last place Jets!
After Ben Roethlisberger overstayed his welcome and held the Steelers hostage for 2 years too long, the Steelers then were blessed by Mitchell Trubisky, Mason Rudolph and Kenny Pickett.
Kenny Pickett is currently in a legit backup competition battle with 6th round rookie Tanner McKee and it has resulted in actual trade talks to get rid of Pickett.
Mason Rudolph should end up being 3rd on the depth chart for the absolute worst QB room in the NFL, and this is coming from a Vikings fan with Sam Darnold leading the charge.
Then let’s not waste time on Trubisky.
With all of that said… George Pickens is entering his 3rd year, which is typically a breakout year, with the best QB he has played x2.
Say what you will about Russell Wilson or Justin Fields but they at least can do something on the field, are capable starters in this league and lead some excitement on offense.
Pickens also played under Matt Canada for two seasons, a coach who has been criticized a lot over the last two years for being one of the worst offensive coordinators in the league, who as mentioned was subsequently fired midway through the season last year.
Pickens is a known as a player with “issues” dating back to his college days when he was said by many to be the most talented WR in the class but also the most red flags, thus he tumbled down draft boards.
Most recently he had a brutal incident where he refused to block for his teammate saying he was trying to avoid injury. However, he did follow up that controversial issue with 195 yards and two touchdowns the next game.
Last year Pickens eclipsed 1,000 yards and had five touchdowns for a team that threw for only 13 touchdowns all season.
As mentioned with Josh Jacobs, positive play can make the world go around.
While Wilson may not be the QB he was, and the jury is out on Fields, they both evoke 100% more respect and trust from Pickens who will benefit from not just better QB play but also role models and mentors.
Pickens also led the NFL with 18.1 yards per reception and had just 1 drop on 106 targets and that was with being the #2 WR on the team.
The Steelers should be a much better team with a true pro at QB and this will significantly benefit Pickens.
Jordan Love, QB, Green Bay Packers
Currently: ADP 84 | QB 10
Will Finish: ADP Top 45 | QB Top 5
Big facts: Love was a first year starter last year, had rough start to the season and still ended as QB5 in points per game last year and finished second in the league in passing TDs.
I don’t get how he somehow is going 10 spots worse this year! Especially when running QBs ahead of him don’t typically finish every season playing all games like they did last year.
Sadly, I am all in on the Green Bay Packers and their offense should be a juggernaut in a pretty weak defensive division that has two teams in a rebuild.
The Packers will be the 2022 Eagles and the 2023 Detroit Lions as breakout team of the year.
The Packers were an 8 win team in 2022, 9 win team last year, this year Vegas has their over/under at 9.5 which I see ending at 11.5 as they finish with 11 or 12 wins.
Quick look at their schedule:
- Colts game – Win
- Titans – W
- Vikings – 1.5 wins
- Cardinals – W
- Bears – 2 Wins
- Detroit – 1 Win
- Seahawks – W
- Saints – W
- Split games against Eagles, Rams, Texans, Jaguars, 49ers, Dolphins
Before you even get to them splitting games against the last 6 games they are at 9.5 wins and then splitting 3 of 6 games gets them to 12.5 wins. Of course leave 1 game for error and barring a Brooks injury the lowest they are going is 11.5 with legit potential for 13 wins.
What does this mean for Jordan Love… well everything really. The team will be winning, their RB will be unstoppable, they have 4 starting calibre WRs and an up-and-coming second year TE who should also make a big leap.
The only drawbacks are just the law of averages his passing TD rank only has one way to go, which you would think would be down from #2. He does play on a run-heavy offense and playing from ahead also means more rushing from running backs.
Finally, he doesn’t run as much as the top fantasy QBs like Josh Allen, Jalen Hurts, Lamar Jackson etc. However, while he does not run as much, he also won’t get hurt as much and I don’t expect some of the players currently being drafted ahead of him to finish the season.
Trevor Lawrence, QB, Jacksonville Jaguars
Currently: ADP 162 | QB 18
Will Finish: ADP Top 85 | QB Top 10
Big facts: The Jaguars have the easiest schedule in the league this year. Trevor Lawrence is 24 years-old. I repeat, 24-years old. Lawrence had a college record of 34-2.
Want to know who is 23-years-old, is a rookie in the NFL this year, had a collegiate record of 37-18, plays on an atrocious team and is being drafted 5 spots ahead of Trevor Lawrence… Jayden Daniels.
Trevor Lawrence is entering his 4th year in the NFL and is only one-year older than rookie Jayden Daniels… what are we doing here?!?! More on Daniels to come.
Yes, count me as one of the people who continues to love pain and picks Trevor Lawrence every year as their QB1 in one of my leagues.
With that said, as much as he seemingly has “let us down” he still finished as QB 12 last year and was QB7 in 2022.
I feel like I am taking crazy pills as yet another young player loaded with talent that added more weapons is being drafted worse than his performance last year.
Sure he lost Calvin Ridley but the Jaguars added Gabe Davis, Devin Duvernay and one of my favorite sleepers in 2024 Brian Thomas Jr. who I think ends up finishing in the top 3 of rookie WR stats this year.
Here are some players going ahead of Lawrence’s ADP:
- Aaron Rodgers. Rodgers finished outside the top 10 in fantasy football 2 years ago with the Packers. This was before he was 40 years-old, tore an achilles and played for the great New York Jets.
- Joe Burrow. Let’s hope this injury that has never happened to a QB or pitcher just magically heals in one year.
- Caleb Williams. while he might actually be a decent fantasy QB, I am out on the Bears hype train.
- Aforementioned Jayden Daniels. My biggest bust candidate.
- Kirk Cousins. What!
I only see progression for Lawrence, who as mentioned is only 24-years-old, which is a year younger than Jordan Love and Tua Tagovailoa and three years younger than Joe Burrow.
I will also not let it get out of my head what a winner this guy is including when he led an epic win in the playoffs against the Chargers in 2022 passing for 4 TDs.
I could go on but again just remember he was QB7 then QB12 and now another year older he is going QB18, ridiculous.
Aaron Jones, RB, Minnesota Vikings
Currently: ADP 63 | RB 18
Will Finish: ADP Top 40 | RB Top 10
For the record, as a Vikings fan I pretty much am as pessimistic as they come and always fade Vikings players outside of Justin Jefferson as I think we are the most cursed team in the NFL.
As it turns out I should have been pessimistic last year on JJ, along with one of my favorite picks T.J. Hockenson.
With that said… Aaron Jones will be a top 10 fantasy running back this year.
People have written Jones off… he is old, Green Bay let him go and thought so little of him they even risked him going to a divisional rival.
1st, this year the Vikings probably won’t be a divisional rival to the Packers as I have the Packers winning the division and the Vikings finishing third… so it wasn’t a huge risk as the Vikings are in a tiny rebuild over the next year, even prior to J.J. McCarthy going down.
2nd, Jones not only ran for 100 rushing yards in all of his last 5 games last year, two of those included 108 yards against the 49ers in the divisional playoff game and 118 rushing yards against the Cowboys in the wild card game.
When it matters AJ is doing great and will likely get a lot more carries in Minnesota than he has in the last couple of years in the pseudo time-share he had with A.J. Dillon in Green Bay.
3rd, Jones is only 29 years-old… sure he turns 30 in December but semantics. Players stay young longer these days with modern science and he has saved a lot of wear on his tires via his timeshare the last few years.
Sure, injuries are a risk since he hasn’t played over 15 games more than once since 2021 and that is also why his ADP probably has taken a hit.
With that said, the Vikings will be running the ball to take the pressure off Sam Darnold and there should hopefully be less people in the box with a healthy Jefferson and returning Hockenseon.
Counterargument… it is the Vikings and we have already; lost our our franchise QB; one player has died; starting WR DUI; starting CB tears ACL first day of practice; DUI player also gets carted off field in joint practice; another starting CB gets hurt second day of practice; Vikings sign Sam Darnold which in itself is a little doomsdayish…
Let’s not even dive into 2023 with the injuries or how I already forgot not only did we start Josh Dobbs in multiple games but he even got us poor Viking souls excited like oh hey… maybe he is really good and all these other teams missed on a gold mine… update, they did not.
The Vikings also somehow have the 5th hardest schedule against projected win totals this year. The Vikings run a brutal gauntlet through week 6 to their bye week so do keep the faith even if it is a tough start… or maybe try to trade for Jones in week 4/5 if he has a slow start.
Or maybe I just convinced you to not draft Aaron Jones… but here we are.
Keon Coleman, WR, Buffalo Bills
Currently: ADP 120 | WR 43
Will Finish: ADP Top 70 | WR Top 25
Big facts: Deon Coleman is 6’4, 215 pounds and any time I turned on a Florida State game he was making the most ridiculous catches I saw all year.
300+ targets have left the Buffalo offense… there literally is nobody incredible taking opportunities away from him.
While I do see Curtis Samuel having a sneaky good year, I just love Coleman for red zone play alone.
With the opportunities he will see along with his freakish athleticism I wouldn’t be shocked if he was a top 4 rookie WR this year in an absolutely stacked class where he was the 8th WR off the board on draft night.
Others players I love to buy at a lower value who will significantly beat their ADP
Geno Smith: Currently: ADP 169 | QB 25 – Will Finish: ADP Top 120 | QB Top 15
Diontae Johnson: Currently: ADP 104 | WR 37 – Will Finish: ADP Top 55 | WR Top 25
Joe Mixon Currently: ADP 33 | RB 12 – Will Finish: ADP Top 12 | RB Top 5
Joshua Palmer: Currently: ADP 168 | WR 65 – Will Finish: ADP Top 120 | WR Top 45
Brian Thomas Jr: Currently: ADP 139 | WR 50 – Will Finish: ADP Top 100 | WR Top 35
Javonte Williams: Currently: ADP 105 | RB 30 – Will Finish: ADP Top 70 | RB Top 20
Pat Freiermuth: Currently: ADP 147 | TE 15 – Will Finish: ADP Top 80 | TE Top 8
Fantasy Football Players To Sell High & Fade For 2024
These are players that I believe will end up well below their projected ADP and have worse years than expected by the general public.
Travis Kelce, TE, Kansas City Chiefs
Currently: ADP 23 | TE 1
Will Finish: ADP Outside Top 50 | Outside TE Top 5
Big facts: Father time is undefeated. Kelce turns 35 this year. Kelce himself literally said he was in self-preservation mode last regular season, why would this year be any different.
Kelce was down 100 fantasy points from 2023 to 2022 and finished 3rd overall in TE fantasy points.
Similarly but inverse to what I have been saying in the Buy Low section, why is Kelce still being drafted 1 when he was 3rd last year and a year older.
This man is telling us he doesn’t care about the regular season, which I totally get, but that doesn’t mean I am spending my hard earned fake money on him at TE1.
Furthermore somehow the Chiefs added Marquise Brown in the most underrated move of the offseason and added burner 1st round pick Xavier Worthy. All while Justin Watson, Skyy Moore, Kadarius Toney, Mecole Hardman and Justyn Ross are still on the team!
Expect not only the ball to be spread around a ton but also a lot more running to make sure Kelce along with the franchise QB is as healthy as possible going into the playoffs.
Jayden Daniels, QB, Washington Commanders
Currently: ADP 118 | QB 12
Will Finish: ADP Outside Top 170 | Outside QB Top 25
Big Facts: Jayden Daniels was a projected to be a Day 3 selection in the 2023 draft before going back to school as a 22-year-old 5th year senior to play against 17, 18, 19 year-olds in college including getting blown out by 20 points by Jalen Milroe who is 2 years his younger.
Let’s not get into how skinny this man is. I saw a meme that said Jayden Daniels at the draft looked like Timothee Chalamet at the Dune 2 premier.
I am not here to body shame anyone, he is a freak athlete but he is absolutely going to get crushed in the NFL. I think his weight is inflated by 10 pounds but even if we pretend he is 210 lbs… Michael Vick weighed the same and was 4 inches shorter, Bryce Young weighs 5 pounds less and is 6 inches shorter.
Daniels got absolutely lit up by younger college players… he is going to get ruined by full grown adult men.
If you haven’t seen, please enjoy this clip someone put together where Daniels gets hit like Looney Tunes characters and I can’t unsee it.
I never and don’t wish injury on any player but Jayden Williams better slide 100% of the time or he isn’t lasting a full season.
As mentioned Daniels was projected to be a 5th-7th round draft pick up until this last year where he doubled his passing TDs and tripled his rushing TDs from the year prior, which was also quadrupling his 2021 passing numbers and again tripling rushing scores.
JJ McCarthy is three years younger than Jayden Daniels and got drafted after his third year. Can you imagine JJ transferring to LSU and giving him 2-3 more years?
Sure LSU had a poor defense but let’s not pretend it isn’t a Tier 1 football school.
Drake Maye is 2 years younger and Caleb Williams is a year younger… which again I say if you put either on LSU for 1-2 more years… just as lights out or more.
Had Daniels strung together 2 great seasons in a row then I am all for it… but only putting together a monster season while being 2-5 years older than everyone else just isn’t it for me.
Daniels also had two 2024 first-rounders at WR, another future 1st round WR and his LT is going to be picked top 3 in next year’s 2025 draft. Daniel’s had a behemoth o-line, of which is going to be a complete flip to this year.
Daniels scrambled on 1/4 of snaps where he saw pressure and that was the second highest rate out of any college QB in the last 10 years behind Trey Lance.
I can pile on Daniels more but let me just remind you it’s not like this dude is going to the Patriots, Eagles, Ravens, Steelers or some franchise who will handle him well… this poor kid is going to the Washington Commanders.
Now, it seems the last couple of years the Commanders have turned a bit of a corner from the consummate trash they used to be but they still have the 2nd worst ranked offensive line in the NFL.
Rookie, skinny running QB with issues passing in the middle of the field and the 2nd worst o-line in the league… what can fail.
Anthony Richardson, QB, Indianapolis Colts
Currently: ADP 49 | QB 6
Will Finish: ADP Outside Top 100 | Outside QB Top 15
Big facts: Richardson had the 49th best completion percentage last year in the NFL… read that again. Richardson in four games had a QBR of 26.3, 89.6, 63.9 and 18.8 in his four games last year.
Big stats: Richardson has a 6-7 record as a college QB starter… also read that again. Richardson had a 54.7 completion percentage in his final year in college. 100th best was 58.1% and I can’t find anything beyond top 100 but I would imagine he ended around 150th+ in the country in completion percentage in 2022 at a major football program with the Florida Gators.
Per Sports Info Solutions he ranked 104th in on-target +/-, which is what they deem the most important metric for QB accuracy.
Here are Richardson’s stats of games he played in:
2020: 4 games, 1-of-2 passing, for 27 yards, 1 touchdown, 1 interception; 7 rushes, 61 yards.
2021: 8 games, 38-of-64 (59.4%), 529 yards, 6 TDs, 5 INTs; 51 carries, 401 yards (7.9 per), 3 TDs.
2022: 176-of-327 (53.8%), 2,549 yards, 17 TDs, 9 INTs; 103 carries, 654 yards (6.3 per), 9 TDs.
There is a lot to unpack here but I can’t get over in 2020 the 1 of 2 passing with TD & INT!
I watched every Richardson NFL game and while he did impress me with his running and play action game… I think he caught teams off guard and you could tell once teams started to realize he had less than stellar throwing mechanics… things started to get shaky. Now with some film I fulled expect teams to be much more game planned against Richardson.
Even if Richardson stays healthy I guarantee not only is he outside the top 15 but he also ends up being a “bust” as an NFL QB.
My most valuable stat for a QB is winning… and I say the exact same thing about Will Levis and a plethora of other QBs… 6-7 at a major school throwing to a 2024 first round WR in Ricky Pearsall.
Get this, Pearsall had 48 receptions in 2021 at ASU, which ironically his QB was Jayden Daniels; then had 33 receptions with Richardson throwing him balls in 2022; then back up to 65 last year in 2023 once Richardson was gone…
Everyone has Richardson has their huge QB riser with a QB6 ranking after 2.7 full-games played in the NFL and 13 starts in college! He has started 17 games at QB with an all-time terrible completion percentage and losing record! What is happening!?!?
De’Von Achane, RB, Miami Dolphins
Currently: ADP 42 | RB 13
Will Finish: ADP Outside Top 100 | Outside RB Top 25
Big facts: All of Achane’s 5 big games came in blowouts.
I am the leader of the “Dolphins offense is a gimmick that has been figured out and after the first set of scripted plays it falls apart” club.
We have seen it both of the last two years where Miami enjoyed ridiculously easy opponent defensive schedules for the first 10 or so weeks then gets found out once they played teams not in the worst 10 defenses in the league.
Go back and look it up… Miami the last 2 years somehow played 80% of their first 10 games against the league’s worst 10 defenses each year!
As you can imagine I am also fading Tua but his ADP actually isn’t anything crazy and if it weren’t for his injury history I might actually think he is undervalued.
The Dolphins also paid Tua & their two star WRs huge this year which means they had some losses in pretty important places like O-line.
Kansas City doesn’t pay their WRs huge numbers letting Tyreek Hill move on, Buffalo doesn’t pay their WRs huge, Brady’s Patriots never really did… but now the Dolphins paid a 15-20th best QB in the league big money and two… not one… but two WRs… make it make sense.
With all of that said… Achane will not be surprising people and getting loose as easy as he did last season as the entire offense will regress.
Furthermore he now has a third legit RB in the backfield with the Dolphins drafting Jaylen Wright in the 4th round and it will probably be in a 3-way timeshare.
He was also injured with two separate issues last year as he isn’t the biggest player out there.
All of these reasons point to the fact there is no way he should be a top 20 RB let alone 13th!
Michael Pittman Jr.
Currently: ADP 28 | WR 12
Will Finish: ADP Outside Top 50 | Outside WR Top 25
Big fact: His quarterback is Anthony Richardson… see above.
I hate to double-dip on one team but I don’t really see a ton of major WR “busts” on the higher end of the WR spectrum this year as lots seem valued pretty well.
However, as I have stressed, Richardson cannot throw the ball so how Pittman is a 12th best WR when his team could end up being outside a top 25 in passing is wild to me.
Richardson also threw three TD passes in 4 games… I just don’t see Pittman getting anywhere near the chances he needs to be a top 20 WR.
Kyle Pitts, TE, Atlanta Falcons
Currently: ADP 69 | TE 8
Will Finish: ADP Outside Top 110 | Outside TE Top 14
Big fact: When someone shows you who they are, believe them.
I went off on Kyle Pitts here in my point #1 of my Fantasy Commandments article so no need for me to dive into him again too much.
However, 36-year-old Kirk Cousins off a torn achilles… I am just not buying it.
This take does scare me a little bit though as Cousins is ridiculous upgrade over anything Pitts has had in the past… just he has had 3 years of us making excuses for him… I can’t anymore, I’m out.
Others players to avoid and will perform significantly below their ADP value
Patrick Mahomes: Currently: ADP 28 | QB 1 – Will Finish: Outside ADP Top 45 | Outside QB Top 5
As Texas Tech Alumni, Mahomes is my favorite athlete on earth right now. I just see them being very careful with him every single year, which means running the ball with running backs more and overall worrying about January… not piling up numbers in October.
Aaron Rodgers: Currently: ADP 121 | QB 14 – Will Finish: Outside ADP Top 160 | Outside QB Top 20
Stefon Diggs: Currently: ADP 35 | WR 15 – Will Finish: Outside ADP Top 60 | Outside WR Top 25
Be sure to see Faneverland.com for everything sports and of course the Fraser Laveay Podcast on Spotify here or streaming on all services.



