2025 Fantasy Football Busts, Sleepers & League Winners

Fantasy Football Busts, Sleepers & League Winners For 2025

It’s almost time! Football season is just over a month away so that means fantasy drafts are ramping up in the next few weeks.

With that said here are some players you should avoid, sleepers (players who will far exceed their current ADP) and league winners (meaning players being drafted in rounds 1-4 that will win you the ship and end up in the top 5 of their position).

5 2025 Fantasy Football Busts Or Players You Should Avoid

1. Travis Kelce

This was my #1 bust from last year’s article here and I hope you listened. He was going #1 I said he will finish outside the top 5… he ended up TE10 last year.

Guess what, everywhere still has him 4th or 5th going into this year. What do you think is going to be different this year with him a year older. He has lost all steps, not even just one, and as mentioned last year he was in self preservation mode for the playoffs, which is all he cares about at this point in his career.

Kelce turns 36 this year, the Chiefs drafted a TE in the 4th round and the Chiefs should have three weapons back full-time that they did not have last year.

Kelce will finish outside top 10 and do not draft him.

2. Christian Mccaffrey

Nothing ends your season quicker than spending a ton on one player only for him to get injured for most of the season.

Mccaffrey last seven seasons games played: 4, 15, 11, 6, 17, 7, 3. For those scoring at home that is out of 16 & 17 game seasons, which means he has played 55% of games in the last 7 years.

He has been a top three highest paid auction player in most all of those seasons and ruined a GM’s team five out of seven seasons. Why are you risking this!

If he ends up costing in the range of 10th/11th/12th RB on the board then by all means grab him…. but he is being selected a top 3 RB again and top 5 player in drafts still! Stop it!

Christian Mccaffrey is also 29 years old… he is a bit of a freak (once every 3 years) so his age isn’t a regular 29 for RBs but most GMs think RBs lose a step come age 27 and all metrics show that.

Still select him but do not do it in the first round unless you want a 50-70% chance of torpedoing your season.

3. Puka Nacua

Puka Nacua is on the sneaky all-injury team (so is Joe Burrow but we don’t talk about it I guess).

11 games and 17 in the NFL then 9, 12, 3 & 8 in college.

Nacua has had a broken foot, knee bursitis, knee PCL, knee swelling and other nagging knee injuries throughout his career.

Now, that is not enough to write him off as he still very well could be a top player. Yet, he is going WR4 and I am not risking a top 10 pick or major auction money on a guy that only has a 70% chance of making it through the season.

He plays very physically, which is great in real football, but not terrific for fantasy investors. I also have my concerns about Stafford lasting another full season as he ages out… and if Stafford is knocked out then his value drops dramatically as well.

Let’s also not forget that Davante Adams is now in the fold again… While Nacua could still lead in targets I just don’t like the mix of his injury history, Stafford already hurt and Adam’s cancerous behavior eating into targets etc.

Subscribe to the Faneverland Podcast with this link here or via Spotify below.

4. All Jacksonville Jaguar RBs

Raise your hand if you are a victim of thinking either this will be Travis Etienne’s year or conversely that Tank Bigsby will be this year’s biggest sleeper only for them both to do equally nothing.

Now to add an even crazier wrinkle a ton of media have Bhayshul Tuten as this year’s biggest sleeper. This is insane considering Tank was always in this spot as the biggest sleeper since he got drafted and now it is 4th round Tuten getting this accolade. Meanwhile there are two other young “legit” starters are in front of him.

This is not to say one might not go off but if you can guess which one goes off, good for you. This is something to avoid or at worst pay minimal money for in an auction or draft extremely late. Etienne is in a contract year so if you can get him mid-late then go ahead but I would not risk a 1/3 coin flip on him with a high pick.

5. DJ Moore

I like DJ Moore and think he is a fine WR. I also think the Bears might actually be a decent team this year if they weren’t in one of the hardest divisions in football.

However, he might not even be #1 in targets on his own team and has two legit TEs also competing for targets. I think he has a solid season but he is currently going WR18.

Rome Odunze is going WR34 and I would gladly take Odunze at 1/4 the cost over Moore. In the end I could see both hovering in that WR25-30 range.

7 2025 Fantasy Football Sleepers / Players Highly Exceeding Their ADP

Here you get a mix of sleepers but also players who will exceed their ADP. CJ Stroud is by no means a “sleeper” but him and others made the list under the guise of being players who will far exceed their draft ADP.

1. CJ Stroud

It is a little crazy to call Stroud a sleeper but right now he is going QB18 currently and I think he ends up top 10.

Stroud’s rookie season he was QB11 and last season his o-line was one of the worst in the league. He also had a weapons season from hell with Nico Collins missing 1/3 of games, Tank Dell knocked out of season, Mixon missing games and I assume dealing with Stefon Diggs wasn’t a picnic.

Stroud got some help on the line this year, new WR weapons in the draft and they have a very easy schedule… I am all in on Stroud & more to come on Collins.

2. Kaleb Johnson

Outside of Ashton Jeanty I think Johnson has a good chance to be the best rookie in this class jumping players like Omarion Hampton &  RJ Harvey before him.

He is in a perfect spot for his skill set & I think we have seen enough of Jaylen Warren. Warren has had the chance to take the keys in the Steelers backfield many times yet fails to do so. I see Warren just as a nice complimentary back and Johnson takes the reigns here.

Last year in college Johnson had the 2nd most runs of 20 yards or more, behind only Jeanty. He was Big 10 RB of the year last year and holds the Iowa record for touchdowns, thus the pedigree is there.

3. Cedric Tillman

I wrote last year how Tillman could have been a league winner, only for him to get injured and fall away a few weeks after he started breaking out.

Obviously the QB situation and just overall Cleveland situation is worrisome but he is worth a late round flier at the end of drafts. He is currently going WR58 and he has top 30 WR upside.

Tillman has multiple Tennessee records and put up some huge numbers in big games against Alabama and others. Tillman also is a 3x honor roll student so, the brains are there too.

He was a third round pick, has great size, speed and if he can just get decent QB play I think he could be legit… kiss of death in that being “if he can just get decent QB play” as he suits up for the Browns.

4. Dalton Kincaid

Not really sure what happened with Kincaid last season but he currently is going TE15 and I fully expect him to be in the TE6 or better range this season.
He has the pedigree, is an absolute beast and I can’t see James Cook stealing the same amount of TDs this year.

5. Justin Fields

I can’t quit Fields, and I won’t. He always does very well fantasy wise when given the chance and his legs alone will get you major points.

He is going QB14 and I see him top 8 this year. I love pairing him with JJ McCarthy or Drake Maye and counting on one of them being top 10.

Subscribe to our Youtube Link for shorts, podcasts & videos

6. Jakobi Meyers

If you are in a PPR league than Meyers should be on your squad. He was WR19 last year with absolute trash throwing him the ball.

Meyers is going WR39 currently and has a significant upgrade at coach, RB & QB. I think the Raiders will be a sneaky decent team this year and if they weren’t in the hardest division in football they might have made some noise.

Meyers should at worst equal his last season PPR value in the top 20 but a chance to do much better.

7. Jauan Jennings

I do not know what I am missing but Jennings finished WR24 last year and this year he is going WR39.

Brandon Aiyuk is probably missing the first 4 games or even more, there is good potential for the 49ers to be back to a normal good offense and no more Deebo Samuel. Jennings should at minimum hit last year’s numbers if not significantly more.

I see Jennings being a top 20 WR and far exceeding his 39 ADP.

8. J.J. McCarthy

Yes, I am a Vikings fan, but I am anything but a homer as nobody hated Kirk Cousins from the very beginning more than me.

McCarthy finally breathes new life into this team after a good but disappointing end to the season from Sam Darnold.

Darnold ended QB9 last year and I don’t expect anything significantly worse from McCarthy and honestly could see more. JJ is going 19th right now and I think he ends top 12.

I would not have him be my standalone starter but I would pay peanuts for him and a player like Drake Maye, Justin Fields or get lucky at Dak Prescott for cheap and roll with two for cheap vs. a top 5 guy for 10x the price.

Other sleepers to watch

Calvin Ridley: ADP WR29 – Will end top 20

Tre Harris: ADP WR60 – Will end top 40

Michael Pittman: ADP WR49 – Will end up top 25 IF Anthony Richardson is NOT the starter

Matthew Golden: ADP WR44 – Will end up top 30

Tetiaroa McMillan: ADP WR31 – Will end up to 20

George Pickens: ADP WR32 – Will end up top 20

6 2025 Fantasy Football League Winners

These are players going outside rounds one or later that will be players that finish top three in their position and win you the league.

1. Dak Prescott

Some of us forgot Dak was a QB5 in 2023, QB4 in 2021 and QB3 in 2019. What is the common theme here… odd numbers. Never take Dak during an even number year but on odd #s, he is your guy.

I am not an astrologist but it seems to be an odd # year so let’s load up on Dak.

His running game will again be trash but he has three studs to throw to and will be in a ton of shootout games.

Dak is currently going QB 14, I think he will end up being a top five QB this season and for the sake of this article I hope top three.

Dak exemplifies a fantasy football rule I have, which is to try and get value with guys who aren’t that great of real football players but light it up in Fantasy.

2. Nico Collins

I love Nico Collins and while he is going WR7 I think he ends up PPR WR3 or better this year. I don’t have anything else to say.

3. Breece Hall

Breece Hall is going RB 16 this year. He was RB7 in 2023 before the monstrosity of Aaron Rodgers came to town.

Breece was ranked top three RB going into last fantasy season, top five overall and I see him jumping back into the top five this year.

I still remember the combine where he tested in the top 99 percentile and had an overall speed/strength score that was the highest of any RB ever.

4. Isaiah Pacheco

Pachy might be the first player I try to draft this season. He is currently going RB26 and I know he ends up in top 15 if not top 10, simple as that.

5. Chase Brown

For a team with zero defense, chalk me up to the RB that is going RB13 and I think ends up RB top five.

6. TJ Hockenson

Last year he was getting over his torn ACL and still had a solid season once he returned. Now, fully recovered and going TE5 I can see him jumping into TE3 this season in the high powered Vikings offense.

Other League Winner Honorable Mentions

Garrett Wilson: ADP WR17 – Will end up top 8

Kenneth Walker: ADP 14 – Will end up top 8

 


Be sure to come back to Faneverland.com for everything sports, the Fraser Laveay Podcast on Spotify here or streaming on all services and the Fraser Laveay Youtube Channel.

 

 

 

 

 

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *